The Trouble With Beautiful Words
You asked AI to help with your website.
It gave you a homepage, three different taglines, a brand voice and a list of reasons customers should choose you.
Quite a lot of it sounds good, actually.
So you ask for another version. Something warmer. More professional. A little more distinctive.
And now you have six versions of perfectly reasonable copy and no particular reason to choose one over another.
Perhaps sounding good isn't quite enough.
What are you looking at?
I could write three pages on the magnificence of a sunset.
The blue slowly deepening into purple. The pink and orange on the horizon, somehow both dazzling and fading. The sun sinking, painting the world even as it disappears.
But if you're admiring my choice of words rather than the sunset, I've rather missed the point.
The same applies to your website. A beautifully written headline is only as good as the understanding it creates. An elegant description of your services is only useful if it helps someone recognise why they need them.
The missing piece is judgement
AI is very good at producing language. Give it a direction and it can generate dozens of ways to express it.
But knowing which version to use requires a different set of skills.
Rather than asking which headline sounds better, ask what each one leads your customer to understand. Rather than judging how well a paragraph reads, consider what your customer knows, feels or thinks differently having read it.
Even if it means discarding a particularly good piece of writing.

There's much to admire in a stained-glass window. But if the purpose of the window is to show people what's inside, you don't particularly want them admiring the glass.
Good copy is worth looking through.

